|
Retirement
Housing for seniors of Indian origin planned
Ajay Ghosh
The National Indo-American
Association for Senior Citizens (NIAASC) had its
13th Conference on April 29 at the Vaishnav Community
Center in New Hyde Park, Long Island. It was undertaken
in collaboration with Indo-American Senior Citizen
Center of New York and the Indian American Kerala
Cultural and Civic Center. Attended by nearly
a hundred participants from the New york region,
the one-day conference and the interaction on
the issues discussed evidenced the success and
satisfaction of all the participants.
Immediately following the breakfast, formal presentations
commenced, and the conference coordinator, Rajeshwar
Prasad, Executive Director of NIAASC, requested
participants to observe one-minute silence in
memory of Virginia Tech's 32 innocent victims,
including two Indians, who were shot dead by a
student who committed suicide. He also requested
to remember Romesh Tewari, NIAASC Board member
and former Treasurer, who died on March13. Dr.
Ashwin Pandya, NIAASC President, welcomed all
on behalf of NIAASC as well as on behalf of the
Vaishnav Community Center.
Guest Speakers for the morning session, Patricia
Walsh Perez, APRN, BC, psychotherapist, Bereavement
Consultant, and Wellness Psychologist, and Rose
V. Bruy, LMHC, NCC, Consultant to the New York
City Board of Education, were introduced by NIAASC
Vice President, MK Ramasubramanian. Their excellent
and comprehensive presentations on "Issues
of Single Seniors with Focus on Bereavement Support
System" with handout packages and visual
explanation, were very well received and invited
an intensive and emotional interaction among all
participants. Ms. Perez handed out a detailed
resource directory of bereavement services that
included General Sources, Hospital-based Groups,
Special Focus Groups, and County-based Bereavement
Support Groups. The session moderated by Dr. Pandya
provided impetus to all and that Indian American
seniors should take steps to develop a resource
entity for their benefit.
Perez identified differences between Grief, Mourning
and Bereavement and elaborated on practical reactions
to loss. She continued "Grief is the natural
response to letting go of someone we love very
much." Common reactions to grief are emotional,
physical and behavioral. Emotional reactions may
include many facets such as sadness, guilt, despair,
anger, bitterness; physical reactions may include
deep sighing, decrease in activity, sleep disturbances,
neglect of self, increased blood pressure; and
behavioral reactions could include crying, seeking
solitude, seeking forgiveness, searching for what
was lost, detachment from surroundings. She indicated
that grief is expressed differently by each individual,
and mourning is impacted by social, cultural,
religious background of each individual.
Bruy, complementing the presentation of Perez,
related a story from the publication "Old
Pig" where a grandmother and granddaughter
explaining to one another what was happening on
'Living and Loving as well as Giving and Taking'
The picture presentation covered the entire cycle:
Beginning, Living and Ending. Participants, many
of them having gone through their personal losses,
admired both the presentations and asked specific
questions. The speakers handled interactive portion,
which at times was very emotional, in a very professional
manner with a great solace to all.
Prasad alluded to a recent study by Yale University
on grieving and hurting. The study has been published
in the Journal of American Medical Association.
It studied 233 people 80 percent of whom had recently
lost a spouse. NIAASC will make efforts to get
the study and post it on its web site for the
benefit of seniors.
The afternoon sessions addressed by Iggy Ignatius
MBA from Lansing, Michigan was on "Retirement
Housing for Seniors of Indian Origin." Dr.
Samir K. Dutta, NIAASC Vice President introduced
the speaker and Mr. Ramaswamy Mohan MBA, NIAASC
Board member moderated the session. Ignatius who
had direct experience in real estate field in
USA, and had done pioneering work on Time-Sharing
in India, focused that he and his wife, Shanti,
have decided to undertake this ambitious project
on a not for profit basis and volunteer their
100% time to make it a success. It was their first
formal presentation in their pursuit to seek input
from seniors and different organizations throughout
USA. Their vision is to build "Bharat Vilas"
in a complex of some 25 acres where retirees could
rent or have a condo. The complex will have 8
Vilas in a circle around a Club House with swimming
pool and other community facilities in the center.
Symbolically it will be like a pizza with eight
slices. Each Vila could accommodate 10 residents
with three double bedrooms and four single bedrooms.
The radials from the Vilas will have 80 condos
that will be more like independent living. There
will be maid services in each Vila and condo owners
could also take advantage of this service. The
focus is on Adult Community. There is also a possibility
that some units could be occupied by other ethnic
groups. Iggy also elaborated on legal, zoning,
fair housing laws and other implications which
will be considered during the development process.
During his input-gathering tour Ignatius will
be specifically asking participants to give their
suggestions on the following major components;
each component having several subcomponents on
the need for such an initiative.
His power point presentation was followed by a
video where he showed how the Vila look like from
outside and inside and how the complex would look
like from an aerial point? Based on preliminary
estimate Ignatius predicted that a resident could
rent in a Vila for $750.00 per month that will
include rent, food, maid services, utilities and
maintenance. The condos will be based on specific
need basis. During the question/answer session
participants expressed general satisfaction with
the project and they also provided some useful
suggestions. Ignatius distributed a booklet on
"Bharat Vilas" and was pleased with
the response. He said it was the beginning!
The event also included brief presentations from
collaborators: Chandubhai Patel from Indo-American
Senior Citizen Center of New York, and EM Stephen,
Executive Director and Jose Chumar, President
of Indian American Kerala Cultural and Civic Center.
Comments were also made about other ongoing senior
programs: Nirmala Ramasubramanian from Hindu Temple
Society of North America, Chandrakant Shah from
Jain Temple, Chan Jamoona from United Hindu Cultural
Council Senior Center, Avinash Suri from India
association of Long Island, Ardaman Singh Madan
from Guru Gobing Singh Senior Center.
Usha Foods provided vegetarian buffet lunch, and
the Vaishnav Temple Senior program recognized
all senior programs and guest speakers with a
symbolic bouquet of flowers. Mr. Satpal Malhotra,
NIAASC Secretary, proposed a Vote of Thanks. The
event was covered by ITV and the reporter interviewed
about half a dozen community leaders including
guest speakers. The channel 57 TV also covered
the event.
Issues
and aspirations of seniors of Indian Origin
Rajeshwar Prasad
General Description
The issues and problems faced
by seniors of Indian origin in the United States
have been surfacing progressively and their aspirations
are dimly visible. The influx of Indian immigrants
to the USA started in the late sixties and early
seventies of the twentieth century. These 'early'
immigrants have already entered the phase of seniors.
Since late eighties family members, particularly
parents and siblings, of these 'early' immigrants
have been joining them in USA. Many of them so
called 'late' immigrants were already seniors
on arrival. Though the number of seniors (60 years
and older) in the USA is over quarter of a million
(about 12%) out of a population of close to 2.3
million Indian Americans in USA, there is no data
available at this time what percentage of these
seniors are early and what percentage late immigrants.
Early and Late Immigrant Seniors
Early immigrants have worked here, raised their
children and grand children here, and have adapted
to the US way of life. They are also entitled
to all the benefits such as Social Security, Medicare.
The early immigrants and their children are adequately
capable of dealing with local, state and national
governmental and non-governmental entities. They
are equally capable of steering through the social,
economic and political systems. They have developed
their own social network. In short they are mainstream
Indian Americans. However, their issues are more
focused on retirement housing, financial and legal
management, and intra-family obligations.
The late immigrants have a daunting
task to adapt to the US way of life. Their support
system or social network is limited to their family,
and at best the family friends. Many of them face
language and/or accent problems; are unable to
maneuver the transport system; receive limited
or no economic and health benefits; over a period
of time encounter family conflicts; and are not
fully aware of programs for seniors. This group
is at a loss to spend their time productively.
They feel lonely as their adult children are at
work and their grand children in schools and colleges.
By and large they are financially dependent on
their children, which make them feel uncomfortable
after a span of time.
Recognition of issues and problems of Indian
seniors
Recognition of issues and problems faced by seniors
was dormant till late 90's. There was no concerted
effort on the part of community organizations
to direct their attention to the unique concerns
seniors, particularly the 'late' senior immigrants,
have. Knowledge of these problems was confined
to the seniors and their families, but did not
surface as a public concern. Even today, by most
accounts, if an Indian faces a problem, his or
her contact is the family; it may spill over to
close relatives and friends. Though there are
networks - governmental and non-governmental -
in USA to address such issues and problems, Indians
rarely venture to take advantage of such services.
There may be a scant number of cases where outside
intervention has been sought.
In late 90's the seniors'
problems began unfolding in public. The Welfare
Reforms Act imposed severe restrictions in benefits
to immigrants arriving after August 22, 1996.
These restrictions affected seniors and their
families adversely. Families of these seniors
on whom they were financially dependent felt the
economic impact of this law, and seniors also
felt a loss of economic independence due to these
restrictions. Hardships felt by Indian seniors
and their families began unfolding in the public
arena, and many communities in the United States
initiated efforts to address these problems. In
addition to economic factors, there were social
and cultural factors for late immigrants. This
encouraged communities to make the issues and
problems faced by seniors' public. In communities
from the east coast to the west coast, there were
vibrations among community leaders in developing
loose and informal mechanisms to lessen these
hardships and burdens by organizing senior citizen
groups. Traditional hesitation and ignorance among
seniors and their families in seeking outside
support was still a big handicap in their efforts
to address important issues. Above all, there
was no centralized Indian information and referral
system. It was in 1998 a national entity for Indian
seniors was initiated that led to the creation
of National Indo-American Association for Senior
Citizens (NIAASC), with its mission to serve seniors
through information, referral and advocacy efforts.
Seniors and their activities in Long Island and
its vicinity
In a population of about 60,000 people of Indian
origin in Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk counties),
seniors' percentage is no different than the national
one. Thus Long Island has close to 7500 seniors
of Indian origin. If the figures of its vicinity
primarily New York City and New Jersey are added,
the Indian seniors will account for about 50,000.
It is a significant number. Like Indian senior
programs from east coast to west coast, the Indian
groups in Nassau and Suffolk counties also initiated
a number of senior programs. New Jersey State
has about a dozen such programs; New York metro
area has eight such programs. The NY programs
are listed below with contact telephone number.
Indo-American Senior Citizen Center of New York,
Ashwin Pandya, Founder, Tel. 516-292-9741; meets
twice a month
Guru Gobind Singh Senior Center, Plainview, Ardaman
Singh Madan, Tel. 631-368-6544; meets every Thursday
Senior Citizen Program of India Association of
Long Island, Huntington, Avinash Suri, Tel. 631-269-7247,
meets once a month
Senior Program of Long Island Gujarati Cultural
Society, Blue Point, Praful Shah, Tel. 631-471-7799,
meets once a month
Hindu Temple Society of North America, Flushing,
Nirmala Ramasubramanian, Te. 718-969-1827, meets
twice a month
United Hindu Cultural Council Senior Center, South
Ozone Park, Chan Jamoona, 718-323-8900, meets
five days a week
Indian American Kerala Cultural & Civic Center
Senior Program, Elmont, Raju Thomas, Tel. 516-358-2000,
meets twice a month
Jain Center of America Senior Program in Elmhurst,
Chandrakant Shah, Tel. 718-934-3048
Activities in these programs revolve around social,
cultural, religious and family issues; gradually
expanding to economic/financial and legal matters.
Lately Indian seniors and organizations undertaking
these programs have recognized the need of networking
and addressing issues that have remained invisible
so far. These may constitute family conflicts
and compromises; communication across generations;
unique problems of single seniors. NIAASC occasionally
provides a forum for the above groups and groups
in New Jersey and Connecticut to interact with
one another. It also provides technical and logical
support as and when needed. NIAASC just completed
its 13th full-day conference/workshop on April
29, 2007 that addressed issues of single seniors
focusing bereavement support system and Retirement
housing for seniors of India origin. India Association
of Long Island held its eleventh senior luncheon
on May 20, 2007 in collaboration with NIAASC.
For more information visit web site of NIAASC
at www.niaasc.org and Web site of IALI is www.iali-newyork.org
Rajeshwar Prasad is cofounder and executive director
of National Indo-American Association for Senior
Citizens Inc., and former president of India Association
of Long Island.
|